Four New Highly Aged Bourbons Ranked & Reviewed

Remus Gatsby Reserve 2023 with lamp on a inn table.

In the latest blind flight we look at some of the newest bourbons that carry at least a 10 year age statement! I will give you a sneak peak of what was included in this latest flight: Preservation – Immaculta, Heaven Hill – Old Fitzgerald Bottled in Bond 10 year, Ross & Squibb – Remus Gatsby Reserve and Wild Turkey – Russell Reserve Single Rickhouse CNF. Now I am sure you will have in your mind which Highly Aged Bourbon you will pick and in all honesty I had my thoughts as well. Needless to say this blind showed me something else!

Glass A

  • Nose: Black tea, charred notes of bonfire smoke, vanilla and lemon peel
  • Palate: Orchard Fruits , cinnamon, charred oak, vanilla and fig. Very dry mouthfeel.
  • Finish: Long dry finish of fig and lingering wood.

Glass B

  • Nose: Bright nose, orange peel, vanilla custard, slight hint of barrel char.
  • Palate: Light palate, lightly coats the palate with a watery feel. Brings forth herbal notes, lemon, honey and vanilla.
  • Finish: Medium finish with lemon zest and honey

Glass C

  • Nose: Traditional bourbon flavors on the nose. Vanilla oak, hints of citrus, confectionary sugar and cherry pop tart filling.
  • Palate: Think mouthfeel, hint of fresh dew on a fall day, lemon zest, herbal flavors or unsweet tea.
  • Finish: short herbal finish.

Glass D

  • Nose: Spicy nose or clove, cinnamon, lemon rind, and tea
  • Palate: Bitter dark chocolate, oak tannin, juicy red apple, plum and cherry.
  • Finish: Lingering bitter finish.

Ranking the Highly Aged Bourbon

#4 – Remus Gatsby Reserve (Glass C)

Remus Gatsby Reserve with black background
  • Age: 15 Year Old
  • Proof: 98.6
  • Mashbill:  (75% corn, 21% rye, 4% barley malt; and 60% corn, 36% rye, 4% barley malt)
  • Price: $199.99

#3 – Russell’s Reserve Single Rickhouse CNF (Glass D)

A bottle of Kentucky Bourbon from Wild Turkey Distillery on a bar with glassware.
Russell’s Reserve
  • Age: 10+ years
  • Proof:117.6
  • Mashbill: 75% corn, 13% rye, 12% malted barley
  • Price: $300

#2 – Immaculta (Glass A)

Preservation Immaculta with a living room in the background
  • Age: 15 years
  • Proof: 118.1
  • Mashbill: Undisclosed
  • Price: $269.99

#1 – Old Fitzgerald 10 Year Old Bottle In Bond (Glass B)

Old Fitzgerald Bottled-in-Bond Bourbon as featured in the Bourbon Lens Podcast
Old Fitzgerald Bottled-in-Bond Bourbon
  • Age: 10 years old
  • Proof: 100
  • Mashbill: 68% corn, 20% wheat, 12% malted barley
  • Price: $139.99

Listen to Bourbon Lens on your favorite podcast app or stream on Spotify. If you’d like to support Bourbon Lens, subscribe to our Patreon, sign up for our “Weekly Pour” Newsletter, and don’t forget to follow us on FacebookInstagram, and X.

If you like cocktails, subscribe to our second podcast, Cocktails with Friends. Cocktails with Friends is hosted by our good friend and partner, Bob Cutler.

Recent Bourbon Lens Coverage

Verified by MonsterInsights